Should Non-Citizens Have Concealed Carry Permits in South Dakota? Lawsuit May Decide Question


In January, a federal lawsuit was filed in South Dakota challenging a state law which prohibits non-US citizens from obtaining a concealed carry permit.  That law, “was enacted in the wake of the terrorist attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, when states were looking for ways to tighten security and guard against future attacks, Secretary of State Jason Gant said,” according to the Rapid City Journal.

“It had tremendous support at that time to make sure only U.S. citizens were receiving the permits,” Gant said. “It had bipartisan support along with several other agencies.”

“At the time, Attorney General Mark Barnett, the South Dakota Police Chiefs Association, the South Dakota Sheriff's Association and the South Dakota Shooting Sports Association all supported the change. Gant said the measure passed without opposition or a dissenting vote at any level.”

But in the suit, one Wayne Smith argued, “that he should be allowed to receive a permit as protected by the Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection clause. Smith, of Sioux Falls, has been a lawful permanent resident since 1979 after moving to the United States from the United Kingdom.”

Source: Rapid City Journal 1/6/11

Resources for Concealed Carry

New! Gun Digest Buyer's Guide to Concealed Carry Pistols

The Gun Digest Book of Concealed Carry

The Gun Digest Book of Combat Handgunnery

Effective Handgun Defense, A Comprehensive Guide to Concealed Carry

Find more resources at


  1. Since when did the Bill of Rights or the Constitution state the rights of “residents” or “inhabitants”? To my knowledge, the Bill of Rights (including the 2nd amendment) were written for CITIZENS, legal citizens, of the United States of America. And in my judgement any other interpretation is a violation of the Laws of this nation and a bastardization of what our founding fathers composed and ratified as the laws of this nation. I don’t care what some liberal/socialist anti-sovereignty fecal track says whether they are a citizen, resident, elected official, or even Supreme Court Justice. Those elected to “serve” as representatives of the true citizens of the USA and those appointed as judges and/or Justices have sworn to uphold and defend the Constitution including the Bill of Rights. To do otherwize is to negate their oath of office and borders on treason, high treason!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.