The .308 Winchester has been an old standby for long-range shooters and hunters for many years, but is the relatively new 6.5 Creedmoor a contender for knocking the .308 off its throne?
For quite some time, the .308 Winchester has been the benchmark of accuracy; a great many shooters have come to rely upon it for punching paper out to 1,000 yards and beyond. Based upon my latest experiences at the FTW Ranch in Barksdale, Texas, I believe there is a new contender for the crown: the 6.5 Creedmoor. The SAAM Precision shooting course offers marksmanship training in field situations with plenty of challenging winds, and targets at a variety of distances and angles. I was able to spend quite a bit of time behind a good 6.5 Creedmoor and see what it was all about. Queue the 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308.
I took the course with my pal Keith Warren, who was shooting a quality AR from Nemo Arms chambered in .308, and we were able to compare and contrast the two cartridges. While Keith and his rifle had great success, I did notice a few things about the Creedmoor that I really liked, and my mind immediately went to the reloading possibilities for this little wonder.
Based on the .30 T/C case (a derivative of the .308 Win. itself), the 6.5 Creedmoor is a medium-velocity affair, with factory loads pushing a 140-grain bullet to a muzzle velocity of just over 2,700 fps, and some of those 140-grain slugs give a fantastic ballistic coefficient (BC), which is part of the magic here. It was developed and released by Hornady in 2007, appearing in the company’s catalog the following year.
Comparing the 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308
Compare the 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308 and, you’ll find the smaller cartridge will retain supersonic velocities for an additional 200+ yards, avoiding that transonic “dirty air” that can give unpredictable results, and making hits at the 1,000-1,200 yard range a bit easier. Like the .308 Winchester, the Creedmoor is a “sweet-shooting” cartridge, but unlike the .308, seeing your impact with the Creedmoor is an easier process, as there is significantly less muzzle jump. The Creedmoor is easier on the shoulder, an important factor for extended competitions or shooting sessions.
The Creedmoor is not a large case, and with the longer bullets that give the highest ballistic coefficient values and best long-range trajectories, case capacity will be taken up by the bullet, so I like the powders that will best fill the case, without being overly compressed. These range from VARGET and IMR8208 XBR up through Alliant’s Reloder 17, IMR4350 and Western’s BIG GAME.
It’s the sleek, sharp 6.5mm bullets that really make this cartridge shine, both at the target range and in the hunting fields. The new Hornady 140-grain ELD Match is available as a component bullet, which means you can take full advantage of the G1 BC of 0.610, to achieve that long-range performance you're after. Berger makes a couple of target-worthy bullets as well, like its 140-grain Hybrid Target (BC of 0.618) and the AR Hybrid OTM Tactical (BC of 0.564), which has been designed for best performance from the magazine-fed rifles.
As a hunting rifle, I like the Creedmoor for deer and deer-sized game, and maybe for animals up to the size of elk, with proper shot placement; that said, the Creedmoor is easy on the shoulder and will allow for excellent shooting. Bullets like the 130-grain Swift Scirocco II, the Hornady 129-grain InterBond, and the Barnes 127-grain LRX would all give a decent combination of BC value and retained weight for deep penetration and a quick kill.
“Wait just a second, Phil, weren’t you the guy who fell head over heels with the 6.5-284 Norma? Wasn’t that your favorite 6.5mm cartridge?”
I’m glad you asked. Yes, I dearly love the 6.5-284 Norma; it is one of my favorite hunting cartridges below .30 caliber, and I wouldn’t hesitate to use it on anything south of a bull moose. But, just like there’s room for the .308 Winchester and the .300 Winchester Magnum, I can see room for both the Creedmoor (which is easier on a barrel and will extend throat life, and allows you to call your shots) and a 6.5-284 Norma (which offers a bit more case capacity and thus more horsepower).
Down at the FTW Ranch, the shooting instructors, mainly comprised of ex-Navy Seals, all shot 6.5 Creedmoor for the reasons I stated above, plus factoring in the availability of good, affordable ammunition. That said, when I return to the FTW for the Advanced Precision course, I’ll be bringing my 6.5-284 to measure what appreciable differences I’ll see at the longer ranges the FTW has to offer.
To answer the question in the title of this article, yes, I do believe the 6.5 Creedmoor will slowly unseat the .308 Winchester on the target ranges. The virtues of this cartridge will prove to many an experienced shooter that the 6.5mm diameter is the wave of the future. Watching an inexperienced 18-year-old young woman progress from “how to load the magazine” to “I just rang steel at 1,400 yards,” in three days of instruction at the FTW solidified how well this cartridge performs. Here’s to the Creedmoor!
Editor's Note: This article is an excerpt from the September 2016 issue of Gun Digest the Magazine.