While becoming less predominant in firearms designs, there are many great examples of pistols that include a thumb safety. Take, for instance, the venerable 1911. Of course, for those who choose to carry a handgun outfitted with this feature, there is an extra consideration. In particular, when in the draw sequence is it appropriate to disengage the safety? Rob Pincus does a pretty solid job of going over the basics of this topic in the above video. Perhaps as important, the firearms instructor and Gun Digest author also talks about when to reengage the safety. Obviously this is a key concern, given adrenaline of a situation that would demand a draw and the light trigger pull of a single-action pistol could easily add up to a negligent discharge.

Defend Yourself by Rob PIncus

Home Defense

In Defend Yourself you’ll learn security fundamentals including evasion, barricading, and non-lethal defensive tactics to stay safe and secure inside your own home from renowned firearms instructor Rob Pincus. This is not a firearms or shooting how-to book but instead emphasizes concepts and principles you can apply no matter where you live, work or play. Pincus teaches you real world tactics to prevail if your home is invaded, complete with tactical drills you can adapt to your own home and situation. Get Yours Now


  1. Hi Rob, love your show and all the great tips. I had a scary situation happen while carring my Colt 1911. At the end of the day when I was changing cloths I noticed my thumb safety had somehow clicked off. I carry in a Blackhawk level 2 Serpa holster. OWB on my strong side. As I carefully removed the 1911 I clicked the safety back on. This however made switch carry guns to my Sig Sauer P-229, also in a Biackhawk serpa level 2 locking holster. I feel much better carring 15 plus 1 with the hammer de-cocked making the first shot double action and no way can I have a N/D. So just to let you and everybody know somehow the safety on my 1911 clicked off and I never knew it till I got home and changed clothes.

  2. Hope he never has a close-in or near contact adversary. Why wait to nearly full extension fully arm. I’d suggest that as soon as the muzzle is clear of the holster (and your body) it is time to fully arm with the safety off. Then one will be ready for a “hip rock” or “close combat” shooting position.

    Frankly I don’t care about the danger to the adversary – just me and bystanders. So if the gun is pointing at the adversary (it is right? – as soon as you clear the holster and rotate) you are able to engage. If you have the distance to extend and get a sight picture, by all means do it. If not then shoot from the “hip rock” or “close combat” positions.

    So if one trains to not disengage the safety until nearly full extension, what do you think will happen when the adversary is at two yards – or even closer?

    Re-engaging the safety is for after the threat is gone – same as re-holstering. Just do it sometime before holstering.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.